These Blackstone Apple Butter Pancakes Taste Just Like Apple Pie

Neal
Nov 1, 2026 • 7 min read

We’re taking fall seriously, y’all. These apple butter pancakes have apple flavor in the batter, apple butter between the layers, buttery cinnamon apples on top, and a cream cheese drizzle to finish the whole thing off.

Is it breakfast or dessert? Once you get a bite with those apples and that icing, I’m not sure it matters.

The trick is balancing all that sweetness with apples that still have a little bite, then cooking the pancakes at the right temperature so they come out fluffy with golden bottoms. You don’t need syrup here. There’s plenty going on already.

From a Georgia Apple Orchard to the Griddle

This started with a family trip to B.J. Reece Orchards in Ellijay, Georgia. We came home with a full peck of apples and plenty of ideas for fall cooking.

Before we ever picked an apple, we made our way around the farm. There were pony rides, a petting zoo, pig races, mountain tubing, and a giant hamster wheel that made racing my sister feel like running a 5K. The shop had cider, apple butters, jams, jellies, Asian pears, and plenty of produce.

But let’s be honest: I was there for the fried apple pies. We sampled those, too, including an apple pastry with cream cheese. Not a bad way to get inspired for a pancake breakfast.

Our apple haul included Granny Smith, EverCrisp, and one little sweet variety I couldn’t identify. That mixture worked out nicely. The Granny Smith brought some serious tang, while the sweeter apples balanced it out.

What Goes Into Apple Butter Pancakes?

Think of this as four parts: cinnamon apples, apple butter pancake batter, extra apple butter for layering, and cream cheese icing. The fully measured apple butter pancake recipe has the complete quantities for the batter and toppings.

For the cinnamon apple topping

  • Fresh apples, peeled, cored, and diced
  • About 2 tablespoons butter
  • About 2 tablespoons brown sugar, adjusted to your taste
  • A pinch of salt
  • A sprinkling of cinnamon
  • Zest from a small orange or mandarin
  • A splash of apple liqueur

For the homemade pancake batter

  • Flour, sugar, baking powder, baking soda, and salt
  • Milk, oil, apple cider vinegar, vanilla, and sour cream
  • About ⅓ cup apple butter

For finishing

  • Additional apple butter to spread between the pancakes
  • Melted butter, powdered sugar, and softened cream cheese for the icing
  • Chopped nuts for crunch, optional
  • The sweet glaze left with the cooked apples

And yes, I used store-bought apple butter. Ain’t ashamed. Homemade apple butter is cooked apples with sugar and spices, blended smooth and reduced until thick. Making your own is an option, but a jar from the grocery store makes this breakfast a whole lot easier.

1. Cook the Buttery Cinnamon Apples First

Start with the topping so it has time to cool a little while you make the pancakes.

You can cook these apples directly on the griddle. I’ve done it before. This time, I used a skillet because I didn’t feel like cleaning a sugary apple glaze off the whole flat top. A griddle is basically a big skillet anyway, so use whichever makes sense for you.

  1. Melt about 2 tablespoons of butter in the skillet.
  2. Add the diced apples and toss them in the butter.
  3. Season with a pinch of salt and a light sprinkling of cinnamon.
  4. Zest a small orange or mandarin over the apples.
  5. Add about 2 tablespoons of brown sugar and a splash of apple liqueur.
  6. Cook, stirring and tossing, until the liquid reduces into a glaze and the apples reach the texture you like.

The orange zest smells incredible with the cinnamon and apples. My wife said it smelled like an expensive fall candle, and she wasn’t wrong.

Don’t cook the apples to mush. I like them softened but with some texture left. You’re putting them on fluffy pancakes, so that little bit of crunch makes a difference.

Diced cinnamon apples in a skillet with a glossy brown glaze coating the exposed pan
Reduce the liquid until it coats the apples, but leave a little bite in the fruit.

As the liquid reduces, look for a glaze that clings to the apples and the bottom of the pan. Remember, it will thicken more as it cools. Transfer everything to a bowl, including that good stuff in the skillet.

I keep the brown sugar fairly restrained because we’re adding apple butter and icing later. Adjust yours to the sweetness of your apples and your own taste.

2. Mix Apple Butter Right Into the Pancake Batter

We’re not just putting apple butter on a plain pancake and calling it done. We’re putting it inside, too.

  1. Whisk together the flour, sugar, baking powder, baking soda, and salt in a large bowl.
  2. Make a well in the middle of the dry ingredients.
  3. In a separate container, mix the milk, oil, apple cider vinegar, vanilla, and sour cream.
  4. Pour the wet mixture into the dry ingredients and combine.
  5. Mix in about ⅓ cup of apple butter.

That apple butter brings its apple, cinnamon, sugar, and spice flavors into the pancakes themselves. You can taste the fall flavor before a single topping goes on.

The finished batter is thick and scoopable. Set it aside while you get the Blackstone ready.

3. Get the Blackstone Temperature Under Control

Aim for a griddle surface temperature of about 350°F to 375°F. Temperature matters more than the position of the burner knobs.

Turning a Blackstone to low and leaving it there doesn’t guarantee the surface will stay at pancake temperature. Heat keeps building. If you get into the 450°F range, you’re going to cook the bottoms too aggressively before the pancakes are ready through the middle.

For this cook, I kept the outside burners around medium-low and the middle burners on low. Your setup may need something different. Adjust the burners, cycle them as needed, or use a cooking area away from the strongest direct heat to stay in that target range.

Do you need butter or oil on the griddle?

I’m a butter-on-my-pancakes kind of guy, so I used to assume butter belonged underneath them, too. But on a well-seasoned griddle, a buttery surface can make the batter slide around instead of staying in place.

One tip that has worked well for me is cooking pancakes without adding more oil or butter to a very clean, well-seasoned surface. Clean it thoroughly, steam-clean away any residue as needed, and dry it completely before adding batter.

The idea is to let the batter stay put as the pancakes rise. That said, my surface was probably a little too dry on this batch. Take this as a technique for a well-seasoned griddle, not a reason to ignore how your own cooking surface behaves.

4. Cook Until Golden and Fluffy

Scoop the batter onto the heated griddle, leaving room between the pancakes. Don’t get too worked up about making every one perfectly round. We’re making breakfast, not entering a geometry contest.

Let the first side cook and look for air pockets developing in the batter. Check underneath for color, then slide a spatula under the pancake and flip. Finish cooking the second side, keeping an eye on the surface temperature throughout the batch.

Apple butter pancakes with golden brown cooked sides on a Blackstone griddle

What you want is a golden exterior and a fluffy, cooked center. If the bottoms are getting too dark too quickly, address the heat rather than pushing through the rest of the batch at the same temperature.

Transfer the finished pancakes to a tray and give them a brief chance to cool. If you put icing on them while they’re screaming hot, it’s going to melt and run right off.

The boxed pancake mix shortcut

If homemade batter isn’t happening, use your favorite boxed pancake mix. Prepare it as directed, then mix in apple butter for that same flavor idea. You can still make the cinnamon apples and finish the stack exactly the same way.

You can also put some of the cooked apples inside individual pancakes:

  1. Put the pancake batter on the griddle first.
  2. Scatter a few teaspoons, or up to about a tablespoon, of cooked apples across the wet batter.
  3. Let the pancake cook from the bottom before flipping and finishing it.

Batter first, apples second. Putting the apples down and pouring the batter over them doesn’t give the same result.

5. Layer With Apple Butter and Add Cream Cheese Icing

For the icing, beat together melted butter, powdered sugar, and real cream cheese that has been softened. Get it smooth before you try to drizzle it over the stack.

Then build your plate:

  1. Set down a pancake and spread apple butter over the top.
  2. Add another pancake and repeat, making the stack as tall as you like.
  3. Spoon the cinnamon apples over the top.
  4. Add a few chopped nuts if you want some crunch.
  5. Spoon or pipe cream cheese icing over everything.
  6. Finish with a little of the sweet apple glaze from the bowl.
A spoon spreading apple butter over a short stack of pancakes on a gray plate
Apple butter between the pancakes adds another layer of flavor and plenty of sweetness.

Piping the icing is completely unnecessary. My wife said it would make a better picture, so that’s what we did. A spoon works just fine.

Apple glaze dripping from a red spatula onto pancakes topped with apples and cream cheese icing

The layers of apple butter add enough sweetness that I don’t think this needs maple syrup. Between the fluffy pancakes, the apples that still have a little crunch, and the cream cheese icing, you’ve got a pretty fantastic bite already.

A Peach Version Is Worth Trying, Too

On that same Georgia trip, I found a jar of Georgia peach butter in Dahlonega. Peaches are one of my all-time favorites, so naturally I started thinking about using that instead.

You could substitute peach butter for the apple butter and peaches for the apple topping. Just pay attention to consistency. The jar I found was closer to jelly than a thick fruit butter, so I’d be cautious about treating the two as identical in the batter.

That peach jar also got me thinking in a completely different direction: a peach-bourbon reduction with a little jalapeño to glaze smoked ribs. We also came home with plans to give a childhood baked-apple favorite a pellet-grill treatment. A peck of apples tends to get the ideas rolling.

For now, though, these apple butter pancakes are hard to beat. Call them apple pie pancakes, call them a fall griddle breakfast, or put them on the dessert menu. Just make sure you get some apples and a little icing in the same bite. That’s the good stuff.

Share

The Flat Top King

My easy griddle recipes, flat top cooking tips, and hands-on reviews to help you make amazing meals for your family.

© 2026 The Flat Top King
Powered by Convella