It’s fall, y’all. Give me a morning in the low 60s, and I’m ready to call it soup season. And a bowl of homemade roasted tomato soup with a buttery, crispy grilled cheese? That’s exactly the kind of lunch I’m after.
We’re keeping this classic, not piling on a bunch of extras. The soup gets its depth from fresh tomatoes, sweet onion, and garlic roasted on the pellet grill. The grilled cheese gets cheddar and American inside, with a little Parmesan on the outside. That salty, crunchy crust is where it’s at.
My daughter helped inspire this one. She says she doesn’t like tomatoes, but salsa, pizza sauce, and spaghetti sauce are all fair game as long as there aren’t any chunks. So this soup gets blended smooth, with fresh basil, cream, and just enough honey to balance the tartness.
Ingredients for Roasted Tomato Soup and Grilled Cheese
The soup quantities below are what I used for this batch. The sandwich ingredients are flexible, because your bread size and your idea of enough cheese might be different from mine. Just remember, we’re making grilled cheese, not bread with a lonely slice of cheese in the middle.
For the tomato soup
- About 3 pounds tomatoes: a combination of cherry, Campari, and Roma tomatoes
- 1 sweet onion, peeled and quartered
- 1 head garlic, halved crosswise for roasting; use about half the head in the soup
- Olive oil, enough to coat the roasting vegetables
- Salt and coarse black pepper, to taste
- ½ bell pepper, chopped, optional
- 1 tablespoon butter
- 16 fluid ounces chicken stock, or vegetable stock
- About 1 tablespoon tomato paste
- About 1 cup heavy cream
- Fresh basil, thinly sliced or torn, to taste
- About 1 tablespoon honey to start, adjusted to the sweetness of the tomatoes
For the grilled cheese
- Sliced bread: I used a rustic Italian loaf
- Butter for the outside of the bread
- Finely grated Parmesan for the exterior crust
- Cheddar cheese
- American cheese for that creamy melt
You’ll also want a rimmed sheet pan, a soup pot, an immersion blender or suitable countertop blender, and a griddle. A melting dome comes in handy when you’ve got a generous stack of cheese.
Prep the Tomatoes, Onion, and Garlic
Cut the larger tomatoes into pieces and arrange them skin side down, with the cut flesh exposed, on a rimmed sheet pan. I like that open surface facing up so the seasoning and smoke can get right to it.
For this batch, roughly 1 to 1¼ pounds of the tomatoes were cherry tomatoes. I cut about half of those and left the rest whole. The whole ones will burst as they roast. You’re blending everything later, so don’t get too caught up in making every tomato look exactly alike.
Add the quartered sweet onion and the halved garlic head to the pan. Leave the garlic’s papery skin on for roasting. We’ll squeeze the softened cloves out afterward, not put the papers in the soup.
Drizzle the vegetables with olive oil, then season with salt and coarse black pepper.
Roast at 400°F for Concentrated Flavor
Heat the pellet grill to 400°F. Roast the vegetables for about 40 to 50 minutes, allowing up to an hour if needed. My batch took roughly 45 minutes. You’re looking for softened tomatoes, released juices, and roasted onion and garlic.
No pellet grill? Put the pan in a 400°F oven and use the same approximate timing. You’ll still build the soup around those roasted vegetables; you just won’t have the light touch of smoke.
Keep the smoke in perspective
This is not a heavily smoked tomato soup. At a higher cooking temperature, a pellet grill generally gives you less smoke flavor than a low-temperature cook. With only about 45 minutes on the grill, the smoke stays in the background. That’s what I like here: a little something different without covering up the tomatoes, garlic, and basil.
I used Smokin’ Pecan pellets, which are made from 100% pecan shells rather than pecan wood. I like the heat and smoke character they give me, and they’re available through our shop if you’d like to try them.
Clean the grill before a high-temperature cook
Before turning up a pellet grill, check for grease buildup, especially after cooking fatty cuts like brisket or pork shoulder. Clean the grill and grease collection system according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Don’t count on high heat to safely burn away accumulated grease. The NFPA’s grilling safety guidance is a useful reminder to keep grease and fat buildup under control.
Build the Tomato Soup in the Pot
The bell pepper is completely optional. I added about half of one because if I can work another vegetable into something my kids enjoy, I’m going to take that opportunity.
- Soften the pepper. Melt 1 tablespoon butter in a soup pot. Add the chopped bell pepper, if using, and sauté until soft.
- Add the roasted vegetables. Transfer the tomatoes and onion to the pot, including the flavorful juices from the pan.
- Squeeze in the garlic. Add the roasted cloves from about half the head, discarding their papery skins.
- Add the stock and tomato paste. Stir in 16 fluid ounces chicken stock and about 1 tablespoon tomato paste.
The vegetables already have olive oil on them, but that little bit of butter starts building richness in the pot. The tomato paste adds another layer of concentrated tomato flavor.
I roast the whole garlic head because the grill is already going, but I don’t want garlic to take over the soup. Save the other half and mash it into butter. Now you’ve got roasted garlic butter for another meal, or even for the grilled cheese if you want to go that direction.
Hold off on adding much more salt at this point. The vegetables were seasoned before roasting, and the stock brings its own seasoning. Everything will taste different once it’s blended together.
Blend Smooth, Then Add Cream and Basil
Use an immersion blender to purée the soup right in the pot until smooth. You can also use a countertop blender that is suitable for hot liquids, following its instructions carefully.
This is where all those separate ingredients become one soup. If you’ve got somebody in the family who objects to tomato chunks, take your time getting the texture right.
Stir in about 1 cup heavy cream, followed by fresh basil. For thin basil ribbons, stack the leaves, roll them together, and slice across the roll. That’s a chiffonade. If the leaves are small or you don’t feel like fooling with it, just tear them. It’s soup, not a knife-skills exam.
Balance the tomatoes before adding more seasoning
Now taste and adjust. I added a touch more salt and started with about 1 tablespoon honey to soften the tomatoes’ tartness.
The goal is balance, not sweet tomato soup. Your tomatoes may be sweeter than mine, so let the flavor tell you how much honey you need. Sugar is another option. For a little heat, you could use hot honey or add crushed red pepper.
Taste again for basil, too. I ended up wanting a little more. The finished soup should have good body, a creamy texture, and plenty of tomato flavor, with the smoke staying subtle.
If you’d like the recipe in one place for your next cook, you can find our smoked tomato soup recipe here.
Build a Better Grilled Cheese Without Overcomplicating It
Now for the other half of lunch. I’m not trying to reinvent grilled cheese. A few small choices make this one really good.
Slice the loaf without fighting it
I usually reach for a serrated knife for a whole loaf, but somebody suggested trying an electric knife. I used the electric knife I normally reserve for fish, and I was honestly impressed with how easily it sliced the bread.
If you already have a suitable electric knife, it’s a handy option. A standard bread knife still works just fine.
Butter outside, Parmesan crust, two cheeses inside
I know mayonnaise gets recommended for grilled cheese, and I agree that it can brown nicely. But I don’t care for the vinegary flavor it adds. I’m a butter guy on this one.
Butter the outside faces of the bread, then grate Parmesan over those buttered surfaces. That Parmesan adds crunch, saltiness, and a little extra flavor right where the bread meets the griddle.
Inside, use cheddar and American cheese together. I like the cheddar flavor with the creaminess that American brings. Be generous enough that the filling holds its own against the bread.
Cook the Grilled Cheese Low on the Blackstone
Don’t crank the griddle up for this. I used only one burner and kept the heat lower so the buttered bread could slowly crisp while the cheese melted.
If the surface is too hot, you can brown the outside before that generous filling gets creamy. A little patience gives you a much better sandwich.
- Place the first bread slice on the griddle, buttered Parmesan side down.
- Layer on the cheddar and American cheese.
- Close the sandwich with the second slice, buttered Parmesan side facing out.
- Cover with a melting dome to help the cheese soften.
- Flip when the underside is golden, then finish the second side, covering again if needed.
Don’t be scared to dome it when you’ve got that much cheese in there. The bread should be golden and crisp, with a melted center, not dark toast wrapped around cold cheese.
Serve It Hot, and Give Dipping a Chance
Ladle the tomato soup into bowls and finish with fresh basil. A little splash of cream on top is optional. Serve the grilled cheese alongside while that Parmesan crust is still crisp.
I’m not always a grilled-cheese-in-the-soup guy, but this combination might change my mind. The roasted tomato flavor, creamy soup, and salty Parmesan crust work awfully well together.
You can use a little less cream if that suits you better. And the rich texture had us thinking about another direction entirely: shrimp stock and some lobster could turn this into a seafood-inspired variation. That’s an idea for another day, not something you need for this batch.
For now, this is exactly what I wanted out of the first cool morning of fall: homemade tomato soup with real depth, a proper cheese-filled sandwich, and nothing overcomplicated. That’s a good lunch right there.


